Personally, I would've gone with #1, because, kisses! She looks spunky and sweet. The second one has better markings, but is kind of mellow, though that might make her a better farm & mother dog.

Then again, my parents chose our dog by letting the three of us loose in a pen with all the puppies. Chamois was the one who came over to my brother, curled up in his lap, and fell asleep. :) She's still the best dog in the world.